Dog Owners – Should You Get a Cat?

If you’re a dog owner thinking about adding a cat to your household, you may be wondering if it’s a good idea. Many people love the idea of having both a dog and a cat, but it’s important to understand the differences between the two and what it takes to create a harmonious household. 

Whether you're worried about how your dog will react or wondering if a cat will fit your lifestyle, this guide covers everything you need to know before bringing home a new feline friend.

Cats vs dogs

While both cats and dogs can make great pets, they have some significant differences when it comes to interaction, maintenance, and care:

Interactions

Dogs are typically more social—following you around the house or begging for attention—while cats are more independent, only wanting attention on their own terms. Most cats can entertain themselves but may enjoy cuddling when they’re in the mood.

Maintenance

Cats generally require less maintenance than dogs. You don’t need to walk a cat, and they’re pretty much self-cleaning in terms of grooming. However, cat owners do need to scoop the litter box regularly and keep their nails trimmed to prevent furniture scratching.

Caring for

While dogs need regular walks, training, and more outdoor time, cats are content staying indoors—so long as they have plenty of stimulation through toys and cat trees. Cats are typically easier to care for if you have a busy schedule, like working in an office or traveling a lot.

Do cats and dogs get along?

Many dogs and cats can live together without issue, but it highly depends on their personalities and how you introduce them. Some dogs are naturally more tolerant of cats, while others may see them as prey or rivals for attention. Similarly, some cats may be more confident around dogs, while others may be shy or fearful. 

If you're unsure whether your dog will get along with a cat, consider your dog's temperament and any past interactions they’ve had with other animals. If you have a working breed with a high prey drive, for example, it may take very slow introductions to make it work—or it may be better to avoid the interaction altogether.

Pros and cons of having a cat

Adding a cat to your family comes with its own set of benefits and challenges. Here are a few pros and cons to consider:

Pros:

• Cats are relatively low-maintenance compared to dogs.
• They’re independent and can be left alone for longer periods.
• They’re generally quiet and don’t require as much physical stimulation.

Cons:

• Extra expenses for food, toys, litter, and vet care.
• Litter box cleaning is a daily task.
• They may scratch furniture or get into things they shouldn’t.

There are certainly many benefits of having a cat, but adoption should be carefully considered based on your own situation. 

Why getting a cat could be a good thing

Cats can be good for humans because...

• Cats provide companionship and emotional support.
• They’re great for people with busier lifestyles who may not have time for the daily demands of a dog.
• Cats can help reduce stress and anxiety with their calming presence and playful behavior.

Cats can be good for dogs because...

• Some dogs benefit from having a feline friend, especially if they’re high-energy and need a friend when you’re not home.
• Having a cat around can provide enrichment and keep your dog mentally stimulated.
• Cats and dogs can form strong bonds, especially if introduced properly.

Signs you may not want to adopt a cat

While cats can be great companions, they aren’t the best fit for every household. Here are some signs you might want to reconsider bringing a kitty into your home:

Aggressive or territorial dog

If your dog has a history of aggression toward other animals, introducing a cat could be difficult and potentially unsafe. Territorial dogs or those with a high prey drive may see a cat as an “intruder” and react negatively.

Lack of time, space, or finances

Caring for a cat requires time, space, and money. If you’re already stretched thin with your dog, adding a cat can add to the strain on your schedule and budget.

Other considerations

Other factors, such as family allergies, frequent travel, or a chaotic household, may make adopting a cat more challenging.

Biggest barriers to cat ownership

While cats are generally low-maintenance, there are some common barriers to cat ownership:

Furniture scratched up

Cats have the natural instinct to scratch, which can leave your furniture looking worse for wear. While there are ways to help stop furniture scratching, it’s something pet parents should expect.

Allergies

Many people are allergic to cats, and even mild allergies can cause discomfort. While there are cat breeds that are more “hypoallergenic” than others, even hairless cats have dander and can cause allergies.

Cleaning the litter box

Litter box maintenance is one of the less pleasant parts of owning a cat. Aside from scooping regularly, if you have a dog, it’s common for them to sneak in looking for kitty morsels. Pet parents can dog-proof their litter box to keep nosy pups at bay, but daily cleaning is still important.

How a self-cleaning litter box helps

A self-cleaning litter box like Litter-Robot can significantly reduce the hassle of cat ownership. It automatically cleans the litter box after each use, keeping it fresh and making your life easier. This can also help prevent your dog from getting into the litter box for, um, snacks.

Don't want to bother with scooping or adding litter to the litter box? Try the Litter-Robot 4 LitterHopper Bundle, which takes both chores off your hands.

Best cat breeds for dogs

While each cat is unique, some breeds tend to get along better with dogs, particularly those that are more social or energetic. High-energy cats like Bengals and Siberians may be more playful and welcoming to a dog. 

That being said, every cat has individual personalities. An adopted shelter cat can do just as well with a dog, while cat breeds that are known to be dog-like may even become best friends with your pup. 

Here are some tips for matching your dog’s personality to the right kitty companion:

• If your dog loves chasing things, choose a calm, confident cat that will not run in fear or in play. (It’s best to limit chasing even if both cat and dog are being playful.)
• If your dog plays roughly, avoid kittens or elderly cats that can easily be hurt. Instead, choose a playful yet confident adult cat.
• If your dog is elderly, laid back, quiet, or anxious, then choose a calm feline counterpart.

How to introduce cats and dogs

Introducing a cat and dog requires patience and care. Start by keeping them separated and allowing them to get used to each other’s scent. Gradually allow them to meet in a controlled environment, supervising their interactions closely. 

1. Use a baby gate and let them sniff each other on their respective sides. This is a great place to start to avoid unwanted interactions. 
2. Once they seem to be okay with each other (e.g. start to ignore each other), you can remove the gate and let them be in the same room. Make sure your dog is securely leashed at first.
3. Always monitor these initial interactions and, if you have to leave the house, keep your cat contained in a separate room until you’re sure they’re comfortable with each other.

Bringing a cat into a home with a dog is possible and can make for a great pet friendship—if done thoughtfully. Understanding the differences between cats and dogs, preparing for the challenges, and taking the right steps to introduce them can help ensure a smooth transition. With a bit of patience and the right tools, like a self-cleaning litter box, both you and your furry friends can enjoy a multi-pet household.

Source: Mars Global Pet Parent Study